Page 8 - The INdian EYE112726
P. 8

EYE ON INDIA                                                      NOVEMBER 27, 2026        |  The Indian Eye                    8


        Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ Triggers





             Political Row, Praise and Protests






              Sonia Gandhi’s memoir on her journey from Italy to India has sparked debate

            over identity and belonging, with admirers praising its personal reflections while

                                  political opponents accuse her of insulting Savarkar



        OUR BUREAU
        New Delhi

              he release of Congress leader
              Sonia Gandhi’s memoir Be-
        Tlonging: A Journey of Love has
        opened up a political controversy that
        goes well beyond the personal story
        of a woman who moved from Italy to
        India, married into one of the coun-
        try’s most influential political families
        and eventually became a central fig-
        ure in national politics.
            While the book has received
        praise for its writing and personal
        reflections,  references  to  Hindutva
        ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savark-
        ar have provoked angry reactions
        from Shiv Sena leaders, protests and
        threats of legal action, turning the
        memoir  into  another  flashpoint  in   Congress Parliamentary Party Chairperson Sonia Gandhi, Congress General Secretary and Wayanad MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra and Lok Sabha
        India’s deeply polarised political dis-
        course.                                 LoP Rahul Gandhi, along with others, pose for a group picture while holding a copy of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir (AICC/ ANI Photo)
            At the heart of the book is Gand-
        hi’s account of adjusting to an unfa-  begun reading the book, praised its   ing lawyers before deciding whether   he said, invoking Savarkar’s imprison-
        miliar country, culture and family,   style and described it as an enjoyable   to initiate legal proceedings against   ment and suffering in the Cellular Jail.
        and  the  gradual  transformation  of   read.                       Gandhi. “I have read a few pages      The protest also triggered a sep-
        her sense of displacement into accep-  “I have started reading it. I am   which have named Veer Savarkar ji,   arate dispute over an image of Bal-
        tance and belonging.              finding it very interesting. It’s a very   and what I have found is that there   asaheb Thackeray. Congress accused
            “When  I  first  came  to  India,  I   good read. The style of writing is very   are a couple of sentences. However,   spokesperson Shaina NC of tearing
        often wondered where I belonged. I   pleasant. It’s an easy read,” the lyri-  there is no reference given,” he said.  a photograph of the late Shiv Sena
        was becoming part of a new family,   cist said, adding that he would offer   He said legal action could follow   founder during the press conference.
        a new culture and a completely unfa-  a fuller assessment after finishing it.  if he concluded that the statements   Shaina rejected the allegation, insist-
        miliar world. Finding my place took   Akhtar also made clear that his   lacked factual basis, but stressed   ing the incident was being misrepre-
        time - not unlike what most young   admiration was not based on political   that he was not seeking a ban on the   sented and threatening defamation
        women in India go through when    affiliation. “I am not a Congress per-  book. “I will cross-check the state-  proceedings against those who had
        they get married,” she wrote.     son but I have great respect for her   ments and references that are made,   twisted the narrative.
            “What  began  with  uncertainty   because I knew her personally once.   and I’ll do the proceedings legally   The  memoir’s launch  itself  re-
        gradually grew into love, acceptance   I am very impressed by her,” he said.   but will not demand a ban as of now,”   flected  its  political  significance,
        and a deep sense of belonging.”       The memoir’s political dimen-  he said.                         bringing together leaders across
            The reflection offers a personal   sions, however, have overshadowed   The controversy escalated after   party lines, including Rahul Gandhi,
        framing of migration, marriage and   its personal narrative, particularly   Shiv Sena leaders publicly tore pag-  Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Mallikarjun
        identity, drawing a parallel between   passages concerning Savarkar, whose   es from the memoir and demanded   Kharge, Akhilesh Yadav, Hemant
        her experience and that of millions of   legacy remains contested between   that publisher HarperCollins remove   Soren and Abhishek Banerjee.
        Indian women who move into a new   supporters who regard him as a na-  passages on pages 201 and 443. Par-  The reactions underline the
        household after marriage. The mem-  tionalist icon and critics who ques-  ty spokesperson Anand Dubey de-  unusual position Sonia Gandhi oc-
        oir’s  title  itself  suggests  an  attempt   tion his political ideology and histor-  scribed the remarks as an insult to   cupies in Indian politics: a political
        to explain belonging not simply as   ical role.                     Savarkar, whom he called a revered   leader whose personal history, for-
        a question of nationality, but as an   Satyaki Savarkar, grandnephew   personality.  “Inside,  it  is  filled  with   eign origins, family legacy and public
        emotional and social journey.     of the Hindutva leader, said he was   poison against our great personali-  role have repeatedly become subjects
            Javed Akhtar, who said he had   examining the passages and consult-  ty—poison. We cannot tolerate this,”   of political contestation.


                                                               www.TheIndianEYE.com
   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12   13